Delete Givebutter Subscribe button after someone donates
It just came to my attention yesterday that Givebutter is trying to solicit our donors' emails after they donate. The screen shot below shows how it appears. Most donors will not notice that it is subscribing to Givebutter and not our own newsletters. I embed code on my site from Bloomerang, Paypal etc, they never try to get my donor's emails. I am very confused by this and it seems like it is a feature we should be able to either pay to delete or should not be a feature at all and Givebutter can market for their own list of names and not try to solicit our donors. Thoughts?
marked this post as
Liran Cohen: wow. Finally! Thank you. This is such a weird thing to have ever done when we work so hard to get and keep donors. Thank you
marked this post as
Chris Bohn: This is great news! It is just not okay that you do this. Try to take our donors info that we work so hard to get!
marked this post as
Hi All - thanks so much for your feedback about this. We're happy to introduce a new feature addition to our Custom Branding package that allows you to hide the subscribe box OR replace it with your own Mailchimp newsletter subscription list. If you already have access to Custom Branding via Givebutter Pro, you can enable this right away in your dashboard. If you're interested in Givebutter Pro, feel free to contact anyone on our team to help you get set up. As a reminder, we also recently launched Givebutter Gives Back, where qualifying nonprofits can receive access to any Givebutter subscription for up to 90% off!
Liran Cohen: Hello - I’ve been building my database and getting ready to begin communicating with my potential donors via Engage. I’m disappointed to read that GiveButter might use my contacts and contact anyone outside of my own communications, and am unclear based on the Change Log whether this has truly been resolved? I have an unpaid account with tipping turned “on.”
Kaycee Walton: Thanks for writing in and sharing your feedback! I understand how this may be of concern, but we can assure you that we do not use your contacts for any marketing purposes unless someone has specifically opted-in to be added to the Givebutter newsletter. Donors are not opted in by default. However, I'm happy to mention that we are working to remove the opt-in box from the donation flow, and we should have an update here soon!
Liran Cohen: thank you for the quick reply! By “donors” are you referring to everyone in our database or just people who have donated? Thanks for clarifying.
Kaycee Walton: Sorry for the confusion. I was referring to both in this case -- neither donors or anyone in your database are opted-in by default.
Niki Chopra Richardson
There should be a way to turn this off - and not necessarily subscribe to anything - in our case we use the Bloomerang integrated emails.
I am not using the 'free' version of Givebutter, I have paid for it through my Bloomerang subscription. So, for those who are using a free version of GB, by all means brand yourself with their materials - but for those of us who are paying - we should not have to dilute our brand this way/confuse our donors this way.
For a fundraising platform to blatantly try and solicit emails from my donors is highly spammy and inappropriate.
I just migrated over from DonorPerfect to Bloomerang, set up my first Givebutter campaign (a free event) and was completely soured by this excessive GB branding all over what I wanted to be a seamless my nonprofit brand experience for donors.
And to give me the opportunity to remove this branding at the Premium level for $100/mo AFTER a nonprofit discount which then climbs to $500 a month next year and then $750/mo the 3rd year is highway robbery!
Niki Chopra Richardson:
Thank you for your feedback on this feature request. I've recorded your feedback to remove the subscribe button entirely as it doesn't apply to all users with the Bloomerang Integration.
Additionally, Givebutter Gives Back is designed specifically for emerging nonprofits that need access to tools, strategy & support to grow their fundraising apparatus in a fast and scalable way for a fraction of the cost.
Your current Bloomerang Integration, billed through Bloomerang, does give your organization access to Givebutter Base, our subscription-free service offering.
Niki Chopra Richardson
Tori Meglio: My apologies, you are correct, I went back to look at my Bloomerang proposal costs ...so if I added the Premium version - the one that for the first year is $100 a month (after I apply to your giveback program), by year 3 I am paying $750 per month? Is that how I am understanding this?
So just because I want to have minimal branding, and not have GB all over my donation pages, I need to spend upward of $1200 a year and as much as $9,000 a year within a couple years??
To answer the question about replacement - I would rather that be a toggle option - whether or not we want to have a subscription option Mailchimp or otherwise. In some cases that might make sense, in others, like sending an event registration to all my donors for whom I already have their emails - it would be annoying and confusing.
Niki Chopra Richardson: I'm glad to clarify.
Thanks for your feedback on this feature. We will share the toggle option idea with our design team.
Regarding pricing can find the details of Givebutter’s subscriptions here: https://givebutter.com/pricing
You’re correct in that Pro starts at $199/mo, includes all of Base + custom branded emails, priority support, first access to beta features, and an onboarding package.
Premium starts at $1000/mo, includes all of Pro + custom branded pages, custom domains and subdomains, a dedicated success manager, quarterly success review
If you have any additional questions about the discounted rates of Givebutter Gives Back Program please reach out through the contact for to our sales team or email [email protected]. 😀
Tori Meglio: Hi Tori! I came across to the topic and learned about the pro and premium packages. Are these plans updated? Also, does the pricing page has all the details of the subscription?
Regarding emails sent after the donation, does Givebutter send the donors branded/marketing emails?
Hi all - Thank you for your feedback on this feature request. As we plan to address this, we'd be curious to know how many of you would be interested in having the ability to replace the Givebutter subscription with your own Mailchimp newsletter. And if you don't use Mailchimp, what newsletter software do you use?
Liran Cohen: Would love to replace the Givebutter subscription with the option to subscribe to our organization's newsletter! We use the Bloomerang email editor for our newsletter. (Or at the very least, disable the subscribe to Givebutter slide. I agree with other costumers that it causes confusion and frustration for our donors.) Thank you!
Liran Cohen: We use Bloomerang email editor as well. once someone donates they are in our database. No need for a separate subscribe. We also connect to Active Campaign for our intro drip series.. Any option to stop the confusion for our donors would be great. But I don't think you need a subscribe once they have donated.. We have the contact at that point.
Liran Cohen: Replacing with Givebutter subscription with our own Mailchimp newsletter would be great! My organization uses both Mailchimp and Bloomerang email editor for communications with our supporters.
Liran Cohen: Yes, this would be a much better option!
Animal Advocates of Howard County
Totally agree. Just opened our campaign and have people asking to be removed. This is awful:(
Agreed! I would rather pay a small service fee monthly to get rid of some of the Givebutter marketing (subsribe to givebutter, receipts coming from givebutter). It's Givebutter everywhere you look which makes some sense because it's free. However many other services, like Donorbox, are free and do not do this. So many things to love about Givebutter, but let me pay you like $20/month so you don't need to market yourselves to my donors at every turn!
Holly Lewis: Yes. It is too much. Plus we are paying them through the Give Butter Tips. But, gladly pay a fee to get rid of it.
Holly Lewis: I'm a paid client and my donors still receive advertising.
Jodi Shumway: oh no. That is not ok.
Jodi Shumway: I hope they will remove this soon!
Hi Deb! We hear you and really appreciate your thoughts on this. We're reviewing internally with our leadership team.
Amber Ferrero: We're paying a monthly fee to Givebutter and yet Givebutter is asking MY donors for a tip. This seems unethical on many levels. I've turned off the tip feature but would like to get rid of the Givebutter advertising. If my donors are impressed with the way our events are handled online, they'll ask who I use. I'll be happy to tell them.
I might be able to see tips/advertising if it's a free subscription but NOT for Givebutter's paid clients.
Jodi Shumway: This makes no sense. I hope they fix this. I still do not understand why they are taking our donors emails.
I could not get a good answer.